Material Change Clause in Health Insurance – How Insurers May Use It to Increase Your Premium at Renewal
Health insurance has become a non-negotiable financial protection tool for Indian families, especially with medical inflation rising rapidly. However, many policyholders are now encountering a new concern: insurers requesting updated health information at renewal and suggesting that premiums may be revised accordingly. The reason behind this lies in a recently introduced provision known as the Material Change Clause in Health Insurance.
This clause, which has quietly made its way into the policy wording of a few insurers, has raised substantial debate among industry experts, consumer groups, and regulatory observers. Not only does it introduce uncertainty for policyholders, but it may also be in direct conflict with the Insurance Regulatory and Development Authority of India (IRDAI) guidelines on lifelong renewability and non-discriminatory pricing.
In this detailed blog, we unpack what the Material Change Clause in Health Insurance means, why insurers are including it, the regulatory implications, and how consumers can protect their rights.
What Is the Material Change Clause in Health Insurance?
The Material Change Clause in Health Insurance essentially requires the policyholder to disclose any new illness or medical condition detected after the original purchase of the policy. Insurers claim they may revise premiums or impose restrictions based on such disclosures at the time of renewal.
Why This Is Controversial
Traditionally, this clause is common in:
- Motor insurance
- Home insurance
- Property insurance
In these products, the risk is reassessed every year, and a fresh proposal form is required.
But health insurance is fundamentally different:
- It is a long-term product
- It offers lifelong renewability
- Medical underwriting is done only once, at the time of purchase
Therefore, asking policyholders to declare new illnesses every year contradicts standard health insurance principles.
Why the Clause Is Creating Anxiety Among Policyholders
This clause came into the limelight after a research discovery by Beshak.org. For years, no one had heard of it—simply because it had not existed earlier.
According to experts:
- It has been introduced only recently
- It appears in limited policies—such as SBI General, ICICI Lombard, Zuno, and Acko
- No major complaints have yet surfaced
- But the potential long-term consequences are serious
What Experts Are Saying
Mahavir Chopra, Founder, Beshak.org, notes:
“We’ve been researching for five years and this clause is not very old. We found it only in a handful of insurers.”
Shilpa Arora, Co-founder & COO of Insurance Samadhan, warns:
“There’s a risk that non-disclosure of new conditions may later be interpreted as fraud, leading to rejection or policy cancellation.”
This makes it essential for policyholders to understand the implications of the Material Change Clause in Health Insurance before accepting any such requirement from insurers.
Why the Material Change Clause Conflicts with IRDAI Regulations
IRDAI has made it crystal clear that health insurance policies:
- Must provide lifelong renewability
- Cannot undergo fresh underwriting at renewal
- Cannot change pricing due to individual claim history
The Master Circular on Health Insurance (29 May 2024) lays down specific protections for consumers.
Key IRDAI Protections
a. Guaranteed Renewability
A policy cannot be refused renewal unless there is fraud, non-disclosure, or misrepresentation.
b. No Penalties for Claims
Insurers cannot deny renewal or alter terms because policyholders made claims in previous years.
c. No Fresh Underwriting
Underwriting can be revisited only if:
- The sum insured increases, or
- The policy is being ported to another insurer
Why the Clause Violates IRDAI’s Spirit
If insurers use the Material Change Clause in Health Insurance to:
- Increase premiums
- Add exclusions
- Impose loading
- Tighten coverage conditions
…it would directly undermine the principle of lifelong renewability.
Understanding How Health Insurance Is Supposed to Work
When you buy a health insurance policy:
- You disclose your health conditions
- The insurer evaluates your risk
- The insurer may accept, load, exclude, or reject the proposal
Once accepted—
Your health changes are no longer relevant to the insurer.
Any disease diagnosed after the policy start date is automatically covered, subject to waiting periods.
A Leading General Insurance Expert Explains:
“If your policy has been continuously renewed without increasing sum insured, anything diagnosed after purchase is deemed covered.”
This is the foundation of health insurance.
How Some Insurers Are Using the Material Change Clause
While not all insurers have implemented this clause, those who have fall into two categories:
Category 1 – Insurers Only Request Information
These insurers ask policyholders to submit updated health details but do not explicitly mention what they plan to do with the information.
Category 2 – Insurers Reserve the Right to Make Changes
This is where risk increases significantly. Such insurers state that they may:
- Revise premiums
- Add exclusions
- Apply loading
- Alter benefits
However, they usually stop short of saying they will outright refuse renewal—because that would clearly violate IRDAI rules.
Why the “Use and File” System Created Loopholes
To speed up innovation, IRDAI introduced the use and file system in 2022, allowing insurers to launch or modify products without prior approval. They must file details after launching.
While well-intentioned, this has also opened grey areas where:
- Insurers can quietly insert ambiguous clauses
- Customers may remain unaware
- Regulators may review only after market complaints
Experts say product management committees must exercise greater caution.
Potential Risks If Material Change Clause in Health Insurance Is Misused
1. Premium Hikes
Insurers may increase premiums citing increased risk.
2. Claim-Based Loading
Even though this violates IRDAI rules, insurers may attempt to justify it through this clause.
3. Policy Exclusions
New illnesses may be excluded unfairly.
4. Claim Rejection Due to “Non-Disclosure”
If insurers claim the policyholder did not report a new condition, it could lead to disputes.
5. Policy Cancellation
Though rare, insurers may attempt to justify cancellation citing “misrepresentation”.
This makes it critical for policyholders to understand their rights.
What Policyholders Should Do When Faced With This Clause
1. Do Not Volunteer Extra Medical Information
Unless specifically asked with proper justification.
2. If Renewal Notice Mentions “Material Change”, Seek Immediate Clarification
Ask the insurer:
- Why do you need this information?
- Under which regulation?
- Will this impact my premium or terms?
3. File a Grievance If Needed
If you feel pressured or notice violations:
- Raise a complaint with the insurer
- Escalate to IRDAI’s Bima Bharosa Portal
- Approach the Insurance Ombudsman
4. Keep Records
Maintain:
- Emails
- Renewal notices
- Screenshots
- Policy wording
These can help in escalations or legal disputes.
Why Policyholders’ Rights Remain Strong Despite This Clause
Even if some insurers include the Material Change Clause in Health Insurance, IRDAI’s regulations override such provisions. Policyholders remain protected under:
- The Master Circular
- Lifelong renewability mandate
- Non-discrimination principles
- Prohibition of individual claim-based pricing
If challenged legally or through the Ombudsman, insurers cannot enforce any clause that goes against IRDAI regulations.
Conclusion – Stay Informed, Stay Protected
The introduction of the Material Change Clause in Health Insurance reflects a worrying trend where some insurers may be testing the boundaries of regulatory flexibility. While the clause itself may appear harmless, its misuse could lead to unfair premium hikes, exclusions, or even claim disputes.
However, policyholders are not powerless. IRDAI guidelines clearly safeguard the continuity and fairness of health insurance products. If consumers stay informed, question ambiguous clauses, and escalate grievances when necessary, insurers cannot override IRDAI’s regulatory intent.
In an evolving health insurance landscape, awareness is your strongest protection.
Based on recent developments reported by Economic Times (ET).
Establishing an IFSC Unit in Gujarat’s GIFT City- Gandhinagar by Estabizz Fintech
